I headed back upstairs, the scent of Matteo still clinging to the sheets, a powerful, lingering reminder of the passion we had shared just moments ago. I gathered the bedding into a heavy bundle and carried it down to the basement laundry room. The familiar weight of the fabric settled in my arms, a comforting anchor against the swirling emotions inside me. I tossed the bedding into the washing machine, added the detergent, and pushed the door shut. The final click felt jarringly absolute, a sharp punctuation mark on an afternoon that was anything but final.
After starting the cycle, I went back up to the main floor to grab a bottle of juice from the fridge. Just as I set it on the counter, the mundane silence of the house was shattered by the rapid-fire buzz of my phone. A hopeful flutter started in my chest; it had to be Matteo. My heart sank, however, when I saw the name on the screen. Mike. Three texts had come through in quick succession. Without even bothering to read them, I swiped and deleted them all. The thought of him sent a wave of annoyance through me, and for a fleeting moment, I considered moving to the next town over just to escape him. The beautiful house I’d looked at would have made a good buffer, but the twenty-minute addition to my commute, the stress of moving, and the drain on my time felt like too high a price to pay for a man who would still attend the same church. It wasn't worth the hassle, the money, or the drama.
I returned to the basement to transfer the bedding to the dryer and turned it on. Back upstairs, I finally took a sip of the juice. Another thirty minutes passed without a word from Matteo. The silence was unnerving. I finally called him, but it went straight to voicemail. “Are you okay, Matteo? It’s been over an hour and I haven’t heard from you. I’m calling to make sure you’re alright. I’m very worried.”
By the time I was pulling the warm bedding out of the dryer an hour later, my phone rang. The name on the screen made my blood run cold: Dr. Maddie Jones, the ER physician who had treated me multiple times during the whole Xavier fiasco.
“Hi, it’s Dr. Jones,” she said, her voice laced with urgency. “Matteo is in the ER and has been asking for you.”
“I’ll be there in twelve minutes,” I said, the words a blur, and hung up. The basket of folded laundry fell from my hands, spilling onto the basement floor but I didn’t care. Matteo’s well-being was all that mattered.
I scrambled through the house, snatching my purse, phone charger, and keys. My car screamed to life as I turned the ignition, and I raced toward the hospital, breaking the speed limit without a second thought. I arrived in a record eight minutes, my heart pounding in my chest as I jogged toward the ER entrance. Max, a nurse I recognized from treating me, greeted me and led me to Matteo’s room. He was half-asleep, his eyelids heavy from the pain medication. The sight of him was devastating. His face was a patchwork of bruises, one eye was black, and his arms and upper torso were covered in dark contusions.
Max guided me back into the hallway to give Matteo privacy. “When he arrived,” he explained softly, “Matteo filled out forms stating that you are his emergency contact and that we could share PPI and HIPAA information with you.”
“What happened?” I whispered, my voice barely audible.
“He was in a car accident. Police are at the scene, and Dr. Jones and I are taking care of him,” Max said.
“Oh my god… is he going to be alright?” I asked. “How bad is it? Please, tell me he’s going to be okay. Thank you for taking care of him, Max.”
“I know you’re scared,” he said, his expression full of empathy. “I promise we’re doing everything for him. He’s stable, but he’s in a lot of pain. We’ll let you in as soon as it’s safe. We’ll get you to him soon, I promise.”
“Can I… stay with him?” I asked, voice trembling.
Max looked at me and nodded. “Yes. We’ll make that happen.”
I settled into a chair next to Matteo after Dr. Jones left twenty minutes later, holding his hand, feeling the warmth of his pulse through the thin hospital blanket. The night passed in broken stretches of sleep and quiet moments, punctuated by his soft groans as he shifted. I stayed, never letting go of his hand, brushing his hair back from his forehead when he murmured my name in half-sleep.
By morning, Matteo was awake enough to speak, his voice hoarse and weak. “Depp…Grl?”
“I’m right here,” I whispered. “Don’t move, just rest.”
He exhaled slowly, closing his eyes again, and I continued to sit, watching the rise and fall of his chest. The rhythmic beeping of the monitors became a strange lullaby, underscoring the intimacy of being there for him.
By late morning, I helped him sit upright, adjusting pillows to ease his discomfort. “Breakfast? I can bring you something.”
“I’m not hungry,” he admitted. “But glad you’re here.”
Just then, two uniformed police officers appeared in the doorway. “Good morning, sir,” one said. “We’re here to speak with you about the car accident.”
Matteo’s heart rate spiked instantly, his hand gripping mine tighter. “No… not now… please…”
I stood quickly, guiding the officers into the hallway. “He’s in a lot of pain. Can you give me a moment?”
“Of course,” one replied, calm but firm as they followed me out into the hallway.
I turned to the officers. “Do you have any idea who caused this?”
The taller officer looked at me seriously. “Your neighbor, Mike, admitted to tampering with his car. He claims it was minor, but apparently it was just enough to cause this accident.”
My blood ran cold. “Was he arrested?”
The officer shook his head. “Not yet. He’s being investigated. Statements from witnesses are corroborating the story that it wasn’t an accident entirely. The investigation is ongoing.”
I exhaled sharply and walked back to Matteo, taking his hand again. “He’s not going to get away with this,” I murmured, my voice trembling. “Thank you.”
I headed back into Matteo’s room. Matteo’s eyes filled with frustration. “I…”
“I know,” I said softly. “Right now, we focus on you. We’ll handle him later. You just rest, okay?”
Matteo squeezed my hand weakly, then took a shaky breath. “Okay… but… I remember… the moment… tire… slipping… and… I think I know who… it’s… Mike.”
“Mike?” I echoed, my stomach twisting with the awful realization that he had heard the police tell me
“Yes,” Matteo said, voice hoarse but firm. “Jealous… he… he did it. Tampered… car… just enough… make accident… I almost… I almost didn’t… survive…”
Tears pricked my eyes as I held him tighter. “You’re safe now. That’s what matters. We’ll make sure he’s held responsible. Right now, you rest, Matteo. I’m here, and I’m not going anywhere.”
He exhaled, relief mixing with lingering fear. “Thank… you… for… staying.”
“Always,” I whispered, brushing my fingers over his bruised hand. “We’ll get through this… together.”
The hospital room felt still for a long moment, the weight of the revelation settling in. But with my hand in his, Matteo’s fragile strength returned bit by bit. And for the first time since the accident, he seemed certain that justice—and safety—would follow.
I stepped out of the hospital room and pulled my phone from my purse, my fingers fumbling as I dialed Kay’s number. She answered on the second ring, her voice crisp and professional.
“Kay, it’s me,” I said, my voice thick with emotion. “Something happened. Matteo’s in the ER.”
I quickly recounted the events of the last twelve hours. There was a pause on the other end, and then I heard her take a deep, steadying breath.
“I’ll call the police now,” she said, her voice filled with a calm authority that I desperately needed. “I’ll tell them you want to take legal action against Mike on Matteo’s behalf.”
I listened as she laid out the plan. “Once I get that squared away, I’ll reach out to his car insurance company with the police report. I’ll explain that I’m now representing Matteo.”
A wave of relief washed over me. “Thank you, Kay. It’s time for a truce.”
“I agree,” she said. “Let’s get this sorted.”
We hung up and I rejoined Matteo, my heart feeling a little lighter with every step.
A few minutes later, Dr. Jones came in, her face holding a tired but reassuring smile. She explained the results of the second round of scans. “No broken bones, which is a huge relief,” she said. “But his lungs, ribs, and a shoulder muscle are strained. He also has a concussion, so he’ll need to be very careful with any movement. Taking care of himself will be tough for a while.”
I nodded, my mind already racing through the logistics. “I’ll take care of him.”
As Dr. Jones left, Tara came running into the room, her voice frantic. “I just got a call from Kay! She wants to know what I can do to help!”
Matteo, his eyes still heavy, managed a faint smile. “The first thing you can do is stop shouting,” he said, his voice a hoarse whisper.
Tara’s face flushed, and she nodded, pulling her phone from her pocket. I stepped forward and took her arm. “Just run the business,” I told her. “Reach out to Kay and me if you need anything at all.” She nodded again, her expression serious, and left the room.
Max returned with a handful of instant ice packs, bottles of prescription-strength Motrin and Tylenol, and a stack of discharge papers. As Matteo slowly got dressed, someone came with a wheelchair for him to use. I walked out to the parking lot and brought my car around to the front entrance, just as Max was wheeling Matteo out.
Once he was settled in the passenger seat, I started the car. “Are we going to your house?” he asked, a flicker of nervousness in his eyes.
“Yes,” I said softly. “Mike was arrested and then released into his ex-wife’s custody, so he’s there. He’s not a threat anymore.” A wave of relief washed over his face.
The twelve-minute drive home took a slow thirty minutes as I drove carefully, wincing at every small bump in the road that made him flinch.
Kay met us at my house and helped me get Matteo inside. She then left to go to his house to get him clothes and other things he’d need. I took a moment to call Matteo's boss. He happened to be friends with the police officer who had been at the hospital and told me he had already arranged a week of leave for Matteo. I thanked him profusely before helping Matteo get settled.
I helped him shower and put him in the spare bedroom since I hadn’t finished making my bed. Once I was sure he was asleep, I went downstairs, tossed the bedding back into the washer, added detergent, and started the cycle. I then went back upstairs to take a shower.
Afterwards, I found Matteo still asleep and went downstairs again, grabbing a few bananas and some bottled water. I carried them up to the spare room. I then went down to the basement to move the bedding to the dryer. When I finally returned upstairs, I slipped into the bed beside Matteo.
We slept for a few hours before we woke up. He was in pain, so he ate a few bananas and took his medication with the water. I asked if he wanted ice packs or heat, and he chose ice packs.
While I was downstairs, I refolded the bedding from the dryer and put it back in the basket. I placed the basket on the counter, grabbed some ice packs, and brought everything up to the spare room.
As I was applying the ice packs, Kay texted me to say she had some of his clothes—and knowing her, it was probably enough for three weeks—as well as enough food to last several millennia. I thanked her and told her she could drop his things in the living room since we were in the guest room and he was undressed.
When I heard her in the hallway, I stepped out, headed downstairs and gave her a hug. She told me that Mike's case would be handled as a civil matter, and she was pushing for a quick resolution. Since Mike didn't have a lawyer and wanted to handle it himself, he had already agreed to pay for all legal fees, a new car, and all of Matteo's medical bills and therapy if needed. I asked her to hold on for a second.
I stepped back into the guest room to tell Matteo what was happening. He pulled the sheet and blanket up to his chin and told me to let Kay in. I did, and he nodded in agreement, accepting the offer. Kay told him that since she was working pro bono, she would not be pushing for legal fees. He nodded again and asked how long the process would take. Kay told him it could take a few weeks but that she would push for it to be resolved within a week. He agreed.
I led Kay back to the front door. She told me that Mike felt horrible and, in the heat of the moment, had only wanted to scare Matteo out of jealousy. Mike had said he would stay away while Matteo was at my house and would stay elsewhere until otherwise said. I asked Kay, “What if he was asked to move?” She shook her head. “It doesn’t look like he would be forced to move.” I nodded, and she left.
I went back upstairs with a few more ice packs for Matteo, but he had fallen back to sleep. I gently replaced the ice packs on his side and put the melted ones back in the freezer. A quick glance at the clock showed it was almost seven, and I knew I needed to eat. I went back downstairs and heated up some of the food Kay had brought over.
Just as I was about to eat, I heard a knock on the front door. I opened it to see Vince, Vic, and Randy all standing there. “What are you guys doing here?” I asked, shocked.
Vince pushed the door open the rest of the way, and they all came inside. “Kay called me,” he said. “She said you guys needed some moral support.” They all hugged me, one by one. “How can we help?” Vic asked, and Randy nodded in agreement.
“That’s so sweet,” I said, my voice thick with emotion. “Matteo is sleeping right now, and he needs to get dressed first and then you guys can all hang out.” They all nodded, and I went upstairs to tell Matteo that they were here.
“I’m so glad you guys are here,” Matteo said, his voice still a little groggy. “I need to get dressed first, then you can help me get downstairs, but I also need some more pain meds.”
I helped him get out of the bed and into a comfortable t-shirt and sweats. He was in too much pain to walk, so I asked the men if they could help him down the stairs. They carried him down carefully, his moans of pain quiet with each jarring step. They helped me get him some food and another pain med.
“You guys can take over now,” I said. “You can do whatever you need to do.” I looked at my phone and saw it was seven, and I knew I needed to get out for a little bit. “I'm going to the office.”
They all nodded, and I left, grateful for a moment to breathe. I got to the office just as Tara and Kay were leaving. “Hey!” Tara said, a look of surprise on her face. “What are you doing here?”
They both hugged me, and we all went back inside. We talked business for a bit, then they both left, giving me a final hug. I texted Vince. “I’m going to nap at the office for a bit and will be home in about thirty minutes.” He texted back, “Okay.”
I fell asleep quickly and woke up forty-five minutes later to a call from Vince. “Are you okay?” he asked, his voice laced with panic.
“Yeah, I’m fine,” I said groggily. “I just overslept my alarm. I’m on my way now.” I heard him let out a breath of relief. “Okay, thank god. See you soon.”
When I got home, Vic and Randy were gone, as it had been overwhelming for Matteo. Vince stayed, though, and I sank into his arms, a sigh of relief escaping me. “Thank you,” I whispered.
He kissed the top of my head and gently pulled away. “Matteo ate really well,” he said. “And I took the liberty of making the bed in your room and moving him. Between the adrenaline p, the accident and everything culminating afterwards drained him. The bedding from the guest room is in the wash, and the second set of bedding is now on that bed.”
That's when I saw Vince's weekend bag by the front door. I pulled away and looked at him. “I’m here to help you and Matteo,” he said simply.
“I’m not sharing a bed with anyone but Matteo,” I said, my voice firm.
“I didn’t expect anything less,” he said, a gentle smile on his face.
“What do you need?” I asked, and he said he was fine. “I had great company, got to know Matteo, had wonderful food, one of your amazing hugs, and I’m happy you’re home safely,” he said. Before heading to the kitchen for water, I asked him, “Am I going to need to clean anything up?” He shook his head. “No, but there’s food ready for you in case you want some.” I thanked him, and he went to the guest room. I opened the freezer, and there was a pint of ice cream with a sticky note on it with my name. On the counter was a spoon, a napkin, and my extra-extra-extra large travel mug, filled with ice water. I smiled to myself, touched by the thoughtfulness.
I ate the ice cream, tossed the spoon into the sink, and the carton and napkin into the garbage. I grabbed my water and headed upstairs. I took out my contacts, stripped, and joined Matteo in my bed.
“Welcome back,” he told me as he pulled me closer. “Thank you for everything.” He kissed me gently then fell asleep.
A few hours later, he woke up screaming from a nightmare. The nightmare was living through the accident again. I called his primary doctor, who came over within a few minutes. Vince came running down the hall and sat with him as I put on a robe and went to get more water, ice packs, food, and pain meds for Matteo.
I let his doctor in and brought him upstairs, telling him everything on the way up. When we got to my room, Matteo was more calm. The doctor turned to Vince and asked, “Which medication did he just take?” Vince replied, “It was the Motrin.”
The doctor sighed in relief. He turned to Matteo and asked, “Would you like a mild sedative so you could sleep through the night?” Matteo said he would as long as it wouldn't interfere with the pain meds he was taking. The doctor said that he’d give Melatonin and left the bottle by him.
As the doctor headed toward the bedroom door, I thanked him for coming. He said it was his pleasure and that if anything changed for the worse, to bring Matteo to the ER and to call him immediately. I promised.
I went back upstairs. Matteo was falling asleep but was still in pain, so I grabbed the melted ice packs and switched them for frozen ones. I took my robe off and rejoined Matteo back in bed.
A soft knock on the partially open door, and Vince popped his head in. He offered to use the rocking chair in the corner while I slept in the guest room so I could get some sleep and he could stay with Matteo. I said that I'd be sleeping in the room and that he was more than welcome to sleep in the hallway so he could be closer in case Matteo woke up again. He nodded, then grabbed his sleeping bag from his car and came back, setting up everything in the hall.
In no time, Vince and Matteo were asleep, but I was wide awake. When dawn broke, I heard Vince get up, shower, get dressed, and make some coffee. He asked me, “How was the rest of the night?” I said that it was quiet but I was in need of sleep. He said that he would set up the pull-out couch downstairs so he could watch over Matteo while I slept. I thanked him.
As he was taking care of that, I got up, put my robe on, and started slowly taking down Matteo's meds (including the melatonin), the empty water bottles for recycling, and a few blankets.
Vince came back up, helped me wake Matteo. I helped Matteo in the bathroom to brush his teeth and use the restroom, and Vince helped him get downstairs. I joined them a moment later once Matteo was set on the pull-out couch.
I gently sat down next to Matteo and asked, “Do you mind Vince helping you out as I rest?” He said, “No, I don’t mind. Knowing the history between the two of you and that you’ll always be connected.”
I laughed quietly and gently kissed him. I turned to Vince and told him to wake me if he needed help. As I headed upstairs, I sent Vince Matteo’s primary doctor’s contact information. I took my robe off again and laid down. I was asleep in seconds.