The night carried that lingering summer warmth, the kind that wrapped around me and made the air feel like velvet. It was far too perfect to keep the top up, so I’d driven home with the convertible open, the warm wind teasing through my hair as the cicadas hummed their endless chorus. Even now, parked in my driveway at ten o’clock, I let the engine tick down slowly, reluctant to let go of the moment.
The scent of freshly cut grass clung to the neighborhood,
that sharp, green perfume that reminded me of being young, of long evenings
when the world felt wide open. I cut the engine, climbed out, and grabbed my
work bag, but before I could sling it over my shoulder, I noticed movement next
door.
A man—broad-shouldered, steady—was carrying boxes up the
walkway of the house beside mine. His shirt clung slightly to his back with the
effort, and something about the shape of him made me pause. Attractive,
definitely. But there was more to it, something oddly familiar in the way he
moved.
I set my bag down on the grass, not even bothering to hide
my curiosity, and called out, “Need a hand with those?”
He looked up, and the porch light caught his face.
Recognition slammed into me.
“Deppgrl?” he said, voice roughened by surprise.
I blinked. “Mike?”
I couldn’t believe it—my former lover turned boyfriend from
the community college we both attended. Two decades had slipped by since those
days, but in an instant, it was him. Older, yes, with lines etched into his
face and a gravity that hadn’t been there before, but it was still Mike. The
one who had once made my pulse race.
“Well,” I managed, a nervous laugh slipping out. “Of all the
people in the world…”
He grinned, shaking his head as though he couldn’t believe
it either. “Of all the streets in all the towns.”
We stood there for a moment, both rooted to the grass, the
air between us buzzing with memory. Then he gestured toward his front door.
“Come inside. I’d offer you dinner, but right now I’ve only got wine and
cheese. Don’t judge—it’s all I managed to unpack.”
“Wine and cheese sounds perfect,” I said, following him
inside.
The place was still bare, boxes stacked along the walls, the
faint smell of paint and cardboard lingering in the air. He disappeared into
the kitchen and came back with a half-opened wedge of cheese, two mismatched
plates, and a bottle of red he worked open with practiced ease.
“Welcome to my glamorous new bachelor pad,” he said, handing
me a glass.
I laughed. “I’ve had worse welcomes.” I raised the glass
toward his. “To surprises.”
“To surprises,” he echoed, and we clinked gently before
sipping.
The wine was warmer than it should have been, the cheese
unevenly cut, but none of it mattered. Sitting across from Mike again after
twenty years was surreal. His eyes hadn’t changed, that sharp, direct way he
looked at me like he was still trying to read my thoughts.
“So,” I said, breaking the silence first, “what’s your story
now? Last time I saw you, we were still figuring out majors and cheap beer.”
He chuckled, leaning back in his chair. “Yeah. A lifetime
ago. I married young, had a couple of kids. Joined the military, spent more
years than I can count being shipped in and out. I’m in the reserves now—less
traveling, more stability.” His expression shifted, quiet for a beat.
“Separated from my wife. We’re leaning toward divorce.”
I set my glass down softly. “I’m so sorry, Mike.”
He shook his head. “Don’t be. It’s not all bad. The marriage
just ran its course. But my kids? They’re incredible and healthy. They’re est
part of me, really.” His eyes softened when he said it, and for the first time
that night, his grin wasn’t a mask—it was genuine.
I studied him, searching for the traces of the man I once
knew. He was still there. Beneath the years, beneath the weight of life, he was
still unmistakably Mike.
“What about you?” he asked, nodding toward me. “Where’s life
taken you all this time?”
I smiled faintly. “Everywhere and nowhere. Work, travel,
burning out, starting over. I’ve had my share of detours. You know me—I never
was good at sitting still.”
“That much hasn’t changed,” he said with a grin. “You always
had that restless streak. I used to think you’d outrun the whole world if you
could.”
“Maybe I tried,” I admitted, laughing softly.
For a while, we traded pieces of the last two decades like
puzzle fragments. He told me about the endless blur of deployments, about
learning to live out of a duffel bag, about how quickly his kids grew every
time he came home. I shared stories of airports and strange cities, of the
risks I took, the chances that flamed out, the ones that turned into something
real. I never told him about the abortion nor the possibility of who of the four
men could’ve been the father.
And when the conversation turned back to the past—our
past—it was almost seamless. We laughed over professors we’d both hated,
friends who’d vanished into the fog of time, nights we shouldn’t have stayed
out so late.
“You remember that old diner?” he asked suddenly, shaking
his head with a grin. “We practically lived there. I’m surprised they didn’t
name a booth after us.”
“Oh god,” I groaned, laughing. “Don’t remind me. That coffee
could have stripped paint.”
“Didn’t stop you from drinking four cups a night.”
I tossed a piece of cheese at him, which he caught easily.
“Some things never change.”
The laughter died down, but the warmth lingered, filling the
quiet spaces between us. There was an ease here, a familiarity I hadn’t
expected.
Eventually, I glanced at the clock and realized how late it
had gotten. “I should let you get back to unpacking. You’ve got a long week
ahead, I’m guessing.”
“Yeah,” he admitted. “But tonight was better than unpacking,
trust me.”
I stood, and so did he. For a moment, neither of us moved
toward the door. Then, with a quiet smile, he said, “It’s good to see you
again, Deppgrl.”
“It’s good to see you too,” I said softly.
The night air was warm as I stepped back outside, the scent
of grass still heavy in the breeze. It took me all of thirty seconds to walk
across the short stretch of lawn to my stuff still thrown on the grass next to
my car to my front door, but everything felt different. My house was the same
and the street was the same. But Mike was next door now, after all these years.
Inside, I leaned against the door once it clicked shut and
let out a slow breath. I could still hear his laugh in my head, still feel the
warmth of his gaze. I hadn’t expected to feel this—this rush, this pull—but it
was there. And it left me standing in the dark of my living room, smiling like
a secret I wasn’t ready to share.